Here’s a roundup of reader recommendations from Pizzavania, our newsletter highlighting the best in Pa. pizza.
Did you know that The Keystone has a twice-monthly newsletter highlighting the best in Pennsylvania pizza called Pizzavania? You can subscribe here.
Readers play an important part in Pizzavania by sharing their recommendations and opinions on the pizzas they love.
Here’s a list of those recommendations, which we’ll be updating regularly.
“Mama Lena’s in McKees Rocks and Ginny’s Neighborhood Pizza Joint in Murrysville. Both are outstanding!”
— Gary Miller
“The grandma pie at Stroud Pizzeria in Stroudsburg is pretty amazing…the slice of pizza you think about 4 days later!”
— Christy Connolly
“Pizzeria Luca in Lancaster. Probably the best I’ve had ANYWHERE, and you’re hearing this from a former South Philly resident who has been on the New Haven pizza tour.lanc
— Gary
“My husband’s family, from Old Forge, favored Ghigiarelli’s pizza. Your review of Trader Joe’s white pizza takes me back to trays of white pizza from there.”
— Wendy
“Bernie’s Pizza in Dallas. Nice thin crust pizza.”
— Stephanie W.
“Rick’s Doughboys in St. Marys.”
— Marilyn Tucker
“My favorite pizza place is Alfredo’s Cafe in the South Side Shopping Center in Scranton. The taste is amazing. Just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Baked not fried. You must give it a try.”
— Ed D’Amico
“Teberio’s Pizza & Pub in Wilkes-Barre. Sweet sauce and plenty of cheese. Great Pizza.”
— Rich Vacula
“Mabel’s Pizza Shop in Clearfield. A totally unique sauce and cheese in a thin, square pizza. You will not find another pizza like it anywhere and I’ve tried! Only open Thursday to Sunday.”
— Eric R.
“Manbroso’s in Aston. Absolutely delicious.”
— Connie W.
“Carlucci’s Express in Yardley. The best pizza anywhere. The best sauce and the freshest mozzarella.”
— Amy Carr
“Sabo’s Pizza in Fairview, Erie County.”
— Daniel S.
“I was so happy to see that you included Santucci’s in your round-up of the best takeout pizza near Philly. I’m a Northeast Philly kid and we used to eat it all the time growing up. Nothing beats it. I love where I live now, but there’s nothing around here like Santucci’s. I always make it a point to get a pie when I’m back home. I can still taste that sweet sauce!”
— Joey M.
“New Haven Pizza in West Chester. My husband and I have been going to this location for over 35 years by my best guess. Their crust is so good and their cheese is also really good.”
— Jo Ann Eller
“I like Grotto’s based out of Delaware. There are two locations in Pa.: Harveys Lake and Scranton. They just announced a location coming to Lancaster near me.”
— Bob K.
“You need to get to Colonial Pizza in Easton. Always great pizza, and plenty of other items too.”
— Sue G., Easton
“Two words: Verona Pizza. It’s in Maple Glen. Consistently unbelievable pies. I dream of their eggplant pie, and their grandma pies are great, too, if that’s your jam.”
— Terry O’Connor
“Augustine’s Club 17 in Old Forge.”
— Robert P.
“Jim and Nena’s in York. The pizza is absolutely delicious!! Our daughter loves the gluten-free pizza too. The sauce is AMAZING, and all the toppings we order are always fresh and wonderful.”
— Annette Coomber
“Venarri’s Pizza and La Casa de Pizza in Lewisburg. Both have been established pizza restaurants in this central Pennsylvania town.”
— Jean G.
“Angelo’s in Wilkes Barre (the original on Hazel Street) is the best pizza for this NEPA family of 50+. Better call early on Friday as there’s a 3 hour wait!”
— Viv & Joe
“John’s of Arthur Avenue in Milford. Combines the best of Pa. and New York pizza. Very community minded and wonderful staff.”
— Will Nichols
“Disalla’s Pizza in Munhall. Family owned since 1954. This pizza is AMAZING. The crust is light and airy, crunchy, the sauce is full-bodied and so tasteful and the cheese—melted everywhere! I’ve been eating it since it was 6 cents a slice, MANY years ago.”
— Ann Marie Scahill
“Palermo’s Pizza in Lansdale. Their Sicilian Pizza is the best.”
— John
“Rosalie’s Grill in Chambersburg for fantastic brick oven thin crust pizza. They also serve the thick crust style which is good.”
— Teresa
“Falbo’s in Latrobe!”
— Lee Ann Smith
“Two favorite pizzerias in Pittsburgh: Vincent’s Pizza Park and Beto’s Pizza. We have been eating Beto’s since we were in high school. Great pizza!”
— Gloria
“Try Berardi Bros. Pizzeria in Feasterville. It’s delicious!”
— D.W.
“Marina’s Pizza in Fishtown (Philadelphia) lives up to the hype. They do big ‘ol, New York-style slices. It’s hard to find great places that serve slices in addition to pies.”
— Joey
“I almost want to keep it a secret, because they’re not open much and they run out of dough sometimes, but, man, Moonlight Pizza in Pen Argyl rivals anything I’ve had in New York or Philly. You definitely need to check it out.”
— Thomas N.
“Affinito in Emmaus is my favorite, and I’ve eaten pizza all over NEPA, the Lehigh Valley, the Philly area, and even some of the really good spots in North Jersey. Affinito beats them all.”
— Bruce
“Jo Jo’s in Hummelstown. Best grandma pie anywhere!”
-Sheila
“My family has loved Vocelli Pizza in Meadville forever. It’s our neighborhood spot!”
— Bryan Harris
“D’Arc’s n Windber. It was worth my trip from Philadelphia!”
— Denis
“Giovanni’s and Sons Pizzeria in Royersford for an Old Forge style pie. Johnny’s Pizza in Bryn Mawr and Wayne for a great round pie.” (Ed. note: Totally with you on Johnny’s.)
— Jeff
“Switchback Pizza Company in Emmaus is a favorite spot for our family. They do a tremendous Neapolitan pie AND they have their own frozen pizza that’s really great!”
— Jayne M.
“Finally made the drive to Old Forge. Sampled a few places with some pizza-loving pals. Consensus: Revello’s was the best of the bunch. I’m still walking off that trip. LOL!”
— Ted Rice
